NIGHT OF TERROR at Creamy Acres Farm

went with some friends and this place is way bigger than I expected. the hayride was probably my favorite part just because there is so much going on. huge sets and stuff hidden off everywhere. i definitely missed things because I was looking in the wrong direction. the clown house was probably the funniest part for us. my friend is deathly afraid of clowns and might have had a little accident. amazing.

October 2026

We drove about an hour to get here and I'm kind of torn on it. It's got a lot going for it but it just doesn't connect.

The ticket line was really long, which already had everyone getting annoyed. Once we got on the hayride it was better. The props and animatronics are really impressive. The walk-throughs are really disappointing. There were so many people being sent through at once that we were basically right behind another group the entire time. You could see people reacting to the scares before you even got there. Kind of hard to be scared when you literally see what's coming.

The actual production is really good. We just didn't have a great experience with the crowding and some of the actors. For what we paid and having to drive an hour, it's just meh.

October 2026

We've been going to Night of Terror for years and I still haven't found another one that I like as much. The hayride is insane and the most involved I have ever seen. You can tell how much work goes into the whole thing. The actors are what really make it though. They got me a couple times even when I knew something was coming. If you're looking for the best Halloween scares in NJ I can't imagine there's any better than this

October 2026

Took my girlfriend here for the first time and she screamed pretty much the entire way through the 3D clown house lol. That place is genuinely unsettling and creeps into you after a while. We grabbed hot cider while we were waiting, greatly appreciated since it was freezing out. Everything moved along pretty well and we never felt like we were standing around forever. Anyone who's been with a freezing girlfriend knows the joy of not having to wait around. A lot to do for the price too. She wants to go back already so I guess I know what we're doing next Halloween.

October 2025

Kids LOVED it! I think I enjoyed watching them react almost as much as the actual haunted house! The rooms were really well done and there was a lot more detail than I expected. My son has been talking about it nonstop this weekend.

October 2025

Still Guessing … okay, I’ll tell you. It’ll only do if you take a walk in my shoes. I awoke to the gate guards ushering us in…little did I know. Agast, the line was overwhelming, and yet, it flew as does the crow. The grub was delicate, and yet offered a strong remission from the irksome waiting. Alas, the line passed as all things will in given time, and into the wagon we marched. The young ones were a test of my patience, with their oo-woos, and their weeaboos, but I appreciate such things. Tests of one’s character will strengthen the soul. Okay guys and gals, here we go… the hay ride. First I must say, I am so grateful to the Lord for allowing me to come here. We are nothing without him, and are created in his image. If you haven’t yet, please repent, for the love of your soul and family. I was blessed to get the LAST ticket into the park, and I’ve got to say, I’d be just as happy with a femal or friend(s) as I was alone. Thus, onto the attraction. The ride was, to say the least, an experience. I mean wow… forty dollars, no one could as for more. The production value was both incredible and professional, the acting…one word… BRILLIANTLYNCREDIBLE. The up… the down.. crazy good actors , props were beatific. Multiple times I caught my heart in my throte, and was frozen with fear. How wonderful ;) I was sitting next to a beautiful young girl, and when the costumes characters ran on board, we shared a mutual glance of, “this is just a show right?” After the ride I was met with three new haunts. We’re walking now, your kidding right? This was where it really began. The harvest, was just bizarre, I was in a group with these sweet girl from earlier, and a colored couple who “let” me take caboose. Who ir why someone would create that terror is beyond my words. Bizarre is really the only word for jt. My only critue is I felt uncomfortable when it came to the halls lined with “finger” like tendrils which closely strokes my skin. It was the rubber and ribbing on them which reallly escalated my sensations. I enjoyed the end allot though, the bath room was really sweet, definitely includes for the younger ones. The foam stuck with me all the way to the next haunt, which the ticket taker and joked about with smiles. The next haunt was insane. Glasses, and jump out spooks galore. At this I was puzzled. I’ve got to be honest here guys… I wish they had put up motion sickness warnings before entry. I’ve never been one with strong sense of tummy, and this really brought out the worst in me. Multiple times I had to take a rest, much to the dismay of those in my group. About halfway through I encouraged them to go without me, I would take one for the team. It wasn’t the first time I’d missed them, I’d naturally lost them in the darkness earlier 🙈 , but i was so grateful to reunite with them once the light returned. Anyways 😏, I was thankfully helped up by the staff who let me rest for a minute while I recovers from my bends. I was alone for the rest of the walk, but I explained myself to the staff, and they let me pass through with minimal fright. The end was really crushing though, I really wish I could make up for it, but the spinning tunnel was to much for me :(. They had to hold up the ride for at least ten minutes as they scooped up. At this point I was solo once more, I’m a one man band though, so I wasn’t intimidated. Onward I pushed into the final haunt, with a vigor that would quickly be perveads to my deepest mind from the pure Terrors inside. Baby’s, children and dolls, oh my, they had these inflated walls to push through? When I met ran into the actors it was a horror, they had only me to focus on, and I’m not use to much attention, so it was both s pleasure and a horror. I pushed through as quick as my legs would take me , and into the light I found myself once more. I knew this was the day of the trail, this tale had come to and end…

October 2023

Absolutely the best attraction in nj..It was worth the 1hr 40 minute ride to get there..We have been to every huanted atrraction in nj the past 15 years.This place overall is the BEST

October 2022

After 30 plus years going they have great customer service and one of the best Hayrides in the Northeast! Also do mention amazing haunted houses and one of the longest hayrides out there!!!! The food truck is awesome a must stop to eat!! Follow my New page Everyday is Halloween Haunted Travels! New Group.

October 2021

Wonderful place, had a great time there.

October 2020

Really fun scares. We arrived late…yet the actors and staff did a wonderful job to give us a wholesome experience. The actors were energetic…it was not like they have been doing this over and over again. So many haunts under one roof. Hayride was interesting and so was the maze. The haunt house was dark and eerie. It was a great presentation…no laggs, no breaks. Zombie paintball was superb. The barn created terror in our minds. Great work.

November 2019